I made it fairly similar to my mom's since that was the one she liked. Instead of the ribbon (I didn't have any blue that I liked), I used buttons with twine. The dp comes from DSVW's Seasons pack. The rest is all Papertrey Ink (of course!).
I used the dp for the pencil. I've found that this works best using a lightweight paper, so I can't use cardstock or even my BasicGrey papers. :( Instead of doing a loop around the pencil, I tied a bow around it and used some sticky tape to tack it to the holder.
Hope your mom loves it, Alicia! (and I hope you have a great time in Cape Cod!!)
Supplies (all PTI unless noted):
Paper - DSVW Seasons, Stampers Select White, Enchanted Evening, Spring Rain
Ink - Enchanted Evening
Stamps - Hero Arts Alphabet
Other - Twine, Blue Buttons, Taylored Expressions twill ribbon, 2" Fiskars circle punch, 1.75" EK Success Circle Punch